The Babylonian Talmud in Selection: Nezikin (Law): Flogging (Tractate Macoth)

This is a 1944 anthology selection from the Babylonian Talmud, drawing from the tractate Makkot, which deals with the judicial administration of corporal punishment, false testimony, and involuntary manslaughter within ancient Jewish law. The text presents rulings from the Mishnah and Gemara on three main topics: the punishment of false witnesses (who receive the penalty they sought to impose on their victim), the conditions under which an unintentional killer is exiled to a city of refuge rather than executed, and the categories of offense that incur flogging of "forty lashes less one." A notable feature is the explicit debate format, where named rabbis—Akiba, Meir, Tarfon, Gamaliel, and others—are quoted in direct disagreement, revealing that Talmudic law was never monolithic but built through recorded argument. One striking passage has Rabbis Tarfon and Akiba declare they would never have voted to execute anyone had they sat on the Sanhedrin, to which Rabbi Gamaliel counters they would merely have multiplied murderers—a debate that reads as a genuine dispute over the morality of capital punishment. The selection also includes procedural minutiae: exactly how flogging is administered, how the strap is constructed, and how a condemned person's physical capacity is assessed before and during punishment. Readers interested in the origins of legal reasoning, the history of Jewish jurisprudence, or ancient debates on proportionality and mercy in criminal justice will find this directly relevant.

The Babylonian Talmud in Selection: Nezikin (Law): Flogging (Tractate Macoth)

Related pages View as graph →