Parapsychology

Extra-Sensory Perception: Part III. Explanation and Discussion: Chapter 9. Elimination of Negative Hypotheses

Summary only - full text stays on its own separately-gated source. Read the full text at the source »

This is a chapter from J. B. Rhine's 1934 academic monograph *Extra-Sensory Perception*, a foundational text in parapsychology that established the statistical methodology for laboratory ESP research. The chapter systematically evaluates and refutes alternative explanations for Rhine's card-guessing experiments conducted at Duke University, in which subjects achieved hit rates far above chance expectation across roughly 90,000 trials. Rhine works through four hypotheses in order — chance, fraud, observer incompetence, and unconscious sensory perception — marshaling statistical arguments (probability values, X-scores reaching 111.2 times the probable error) and procedural controls (double witnessing, screened cards, distance trials up to 250 miles) to dismiss each. The work is notable for its insistence on treating ESP as a scientifically quantifiable phenomenon subject to the same evidential standards as any other psychological research, and for Rhine's confident, cumulative rhetorical strategy of narrowing the field of plausible explanations until only genuine extra-sensory perception remains. A distinctive claim is that results actually improved with more rigorous technique — the inverse of what fraud or incompetence would predict — and that the sheer number of independent witnesses, subjects, and assistants makes coordinated deception implausible.

Extra-Sensory Perception: Part III. Explanation and Discussion: Chapter 9. Elimination of Negative Hypotheses

Related pages View as graph →